Correlation Between Mainstay and First Trust

Can any of the company-specific risk be diversified away by investing in both Mainstay and First Trust at the same time? Although using a correlation coefficient on its own may not help to predict future stock returns, this module helps to understand the diversifiable risk of combining Mainstay and First Trust into the same portfolio, which is an essential part of the fundamental portfolio management process.

By analyzing existing cross correlation between Mainstay Sp 500 and First Trust Intermediate, you can compare the effects of market volatilities on Mainstay and First Trust and check how they will diversify away market risk if combined in the same portfolio for a given time horizon. You can also utilize pair trading strategies of matching a long position in Mainstay with a short position of First Trust. Check out your portfolio center. Please also check ongoing floating volatility patterns of Mainstay and First Trust.

Diversification Opportunities for Mainstay and First Trust

0.58

Correlation Coefficient

Mainstay  First Trust

Very weak diversification

The 3 months correlation between Mainstay and First is 0.58. Overlapping area represents the amount of risk that can be diversified away by holding Mainstay Sp 500 and First Trust Intermediate in the same portfolio, assuming nothing else is changed. The correlation between historical prices or returns on First Trust Intermediate and Mainstay is a relative statistical measure of the degree to which these equity instruments tend to move together. The correlation coefficient measures the extent to which returns on Mainstay Sp 500 are associated (or correlated) with First Trust. Values of the correlation coefficient range from -1 to +1, where. The correlation of zero (0) is possible when the price movement of First Trust Intermediate has no effect on the direction of Mainstay i.e., Mainstay and First Trust go up and down completely randomly.

Pair Corralation between Mainstay and First Trust

Assuming the 90 days horizon Mainstay Sp 500 is expected to generate 1.68 times more return on investment than First Trust. However, Mainstay is 1.68 times more volatile than First Trust Intermediate. It trades about 0.32 of its potential returns per unit of risk. First Trust Intermediate is currently generating about 0.34 per unit of risk. If you would invest  6,040  in Mainstay Sp 500 on April 26, 2025 and sell it today you would earn a total of  929.00  from holding Mainstay Sp 500 or generate 15.38% return on investment over 90 days.

Time Period	3 Months [change]
Direction	Moves Together
Strength	Weak
Accuracy	100.0%
Values	Daily Returns

Mainstay Sp 500  vs.  First Trust Intermediate

Mainstay Sp 500

Risk-Adjusted Performance

Solid

Compared to the overall equity markets, risk-adjusted returns on investments in Mainstay Sp 500 are ranked lower than 25 (%) of all funds and portfolios of funds over the last 90 days. In spite of fairly weak forward indicators, Mainstay showed solid returns over the last few months and may actually be approaching a breakup point.

First Trust Intermediate

Risk-Adjusted Performance

Strong

Compared to the overall equity markets, risk-adjusted returns on investments in First Trust Intermediate are ranked lower than 26 (%) of all funds and portfolios of funds over the last 90 days. Despite nearly fragile basic indicators, First Trust may actually be approaching a critical reversion point that can send shares even higher in August 2025.

Pair Trading with Mainstay and First Trust

The main advantage of trading using opposite Mainstay and First Trust positions is that it hedges away some unsystematic risk. Because of two separate transactions, even if Mainstay position performs unexpectedly, First Trust can make up some of the losses. Pair trading also minimizes risk from directional movements in the market. For example, if an entire industry or sector drops because of unexpected headlines, the short position in First Trust will offset losses from the drop in First Trust's long position.

The idea behind Mainstay Sp 500 and First Trust Intermediate pairs trading is to make the combined position market-neutral, meaning the overall market's direction will not affect its win or loss (or potential downside or upside). This can be achieved by designing a pairs trade with two highly correlated stocks or equities that operate in a similar space or sector, making it possible to obtain profits through simple and relatively low-risk investment.

Check out your portfolio center.

Note that this page's information should be used as a complementary analysis to find the right mix of equity instruments to add to your existing portfolios or create a brand new portfolio. You can also try the Portfolio Rebalancing module to analyze risk-adjusted returns against different time horizons to find asset-allocation targets.