Carnival Stock Beneish M Score

CCL Stock  USD 24.90  0.45  1.78%   
This module uses fundamental data of Carnival to approximate the value of its Beneish M Score. Carnival M Score tells investors if the company management is likely to be manipulating earnings. The score is calculated using eight financial indicators that are adjusted by a specific multiplier. Please note, the M Score is a probabilistic model and cannot detect companies that manipulate their earnings with 100% accuracy. Check out Carnival Piotroski F Score and Carnival Altman Z Score analysis.
For more information on how to buy Carnival Stock please use our How to buy in Carnival Stock guide.
  
At this time, Carnival's Short and Long Term Debt is quite stable compared to the past year. Net Debt To EBITDA is expected to rise to 8.19 this year, although the value of Cash Flow To Debt Ratio will most likely fall to 0.15. At this time, Carnival's ROIC is quite stable compared to the past year. Capex To Revenue is expected to rise to 0.25 this year, although the value of PTB Ratio will most likely fall to 2.66.
At this time, it appears that Carnival is a possible manipulator. The earnings manipulation may begin if Carnival's top management creates an artificial sense of financial success, forcing the stock price to be traded at a high price-earnings multiple than it should be. In general, excessive earnings management by Carnival executives may lead to removing some of the operating profits from subsequent periods to inflate earnings in the following periods. This way, the manipulation of Carnival's earnings can lead to misrepresentations of actual financial condition, taking the otherwise loyal stakeholders on to the path of questionable ethical practices and plain fraud.
-1.62
Beneish M Score - Possible Manipulator
Elasticity of Receivables

1.0

Focus
Asset Quality

3.87

Focus
Expense Coverage

1.0

Focus
Gross Margin Strengs

0.92

Focus
Accruals Factor

1.0

Focus
Depreciation Resistance

0.65

Focus
Net Sales Growth

1.05

Focus
Financial Leverage Condition

1.0

Focus

Carnival Beneish M-Score Indicator Trends

The cure to earnings manipulation is the transparency of financial reporting. It will typically remove the temptation of the top executives to inflate earnings (i.e., to promote the idea of 'winning at any cost'). Because a healthy internal audit department can enhance transparency, the board should promote the auditors' access to all the record-keeping systems across the enterprise. For example, if Carnival's auditors report directly to the board (not management), the managers will be reluctant to manipulate simply due to the fear of punishment. On the other hand, the auditors will be free to investigate the ledgers properly because they know that the board has their back.
Current ValueLast YearChange From Last Year 10 Year Trend
Net Receivables671.4 M639.4 M
Sufficiently Up
Pretty Stable
Total Revenue26.1 B24.8 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Total Assets59.3 B56.5 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Total Current Assets6.4 B6.1 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Non Current Assets Total53 B50.4 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Property Plant Equipment31.3 B47.6 B
Way Down
Slightly volatile
Depreciation And Amortization2.9 B2.7 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Selling General Administrative3.6 B3.4 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Total Current Liabilities13.9 B13.2 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Non Current Liabilities Total37.1 B35.4 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Net Debt35.6 B33.9 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Short Term Debt2.9 B2.7 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Long Term Debt34.4 B32.8 B
Sufficiently Up
Slightly volatile
Long Term Investments145.8 M280.6 M
Way Down
Slightly volatile

Carnival Beneish M-Score Driver Matrix

One of the toughest challenges investors face today is learning how to quickly synthesize historical financial statements and information provided by the company, SEC reporting, and various external parties in order to detect the potential manipulation of earnings. Understanding the correlation between Carnival's different financial indicators related to revenue, expenses, operating profit, and net earnings helps investors identify and prioritize their investing strategies towards Carnival in a much-optimized way. Analyzing correlations between earnings drivers directly associated with dollar figures is the most effective way to find Carnival's degree of accounting gimmicks and manipulations.

About Carnival Beneish M Score

M-Score is one of many grading techniques for value stocks. It was developed by Professor M. Daniel Beneish of the Kelley School of Business at Indiana University and published in 1999 under the paper titled The Detection of Earnings Manipulation. The Beneish score is a multi-factor model that utilizes financial identifiers to compile eight variables used to classify whether a company has manipulated its reported earnings. The variables are built from the officially filed financial statements to create a final score call 'M Score.' The score helps to identify companies that are likely to manipulate their profits if they show deteriorating gross margins, operating expenses, and leverage against growing revenue.

Other Operating Expenses

23.71 Billion

At this time, Carnival's Other Operating Expenses is quite stable compared to the past year.

Carnival Earnings Manipulation Drivers

Although earnings manipulation is typically not the result of intentional misconduct by the c-level executives, it is still a widespread practice by the senior management of public companies such as Carnival. It is usually done by a series of misrepresentations of various accounting rules and operating activities across multiple financial cycles. The best way to spot the manipulation is to examine the historical financial statement to find inconsistencies in earning reports to find trends in assets or liabilities that are not sustainable in the future.
201920202021202220232024 (projected)
Net Receivables273M246M395M556M639.4M671.4M
Total Revenue5.6B1.9B12.2B21.6B24.8B26.1B
Total Assets53.6B53.3B51.7B49.1B56.5B59.3B
Total Current Assets10.6B10.1B7.5B5.3B6.1B6.4B
Net Debt18.9B25.7B31.9B29.5B33.9B35.6B
Short Term Debt5.1B4.9B2.7B2.4B2.7B2.9B
Long Term Debt22.1B28.5B32.0B28.5B32.8B34.4B
Operating Income(8.9B)(7.1B)(4.4B)2.0B1.8B1.8B
Investments(81M)(290M)199M(3.6B)(3.3B)(3.1B)
Gross Profit Margin(0.47)(1.44)0.03390.340.390.36

Carnival ESG Sustainability

Some studies have found that companies with high sustainability scores are getting higher valuations than competitors with lower social-engagement activities. While most ESG disclosures are voluntary and do not directly affect the long term financial condition, Carnival's sustainability indicators can be used to identify proper investment strategies using environmental, social, and governance scores that are crucial to Carnival's managers, analysts, and investors.
Environmental
Governance
Social

About Carnival Fundamental Analysis

The Macroaxis Fundamental Analysis modules help investors analyze Carnival's financials across various querterly and yearly statements, indicators and fundamental ratios. We help investors to determine the real value of Carnival using virtually all public information available. We use both quantitative as well as qualitative analysis to arrive at the intrinsic value of Carnival based on its fundamental data. In general, a quantitative approach, as applied to this company, focuses on analyzing financial statements comparatively, whereas a qaualitative method uses data that is important to a company's growth but cannot be measured and presented in a numerical way.
Please read more on our fundamental analysis page.

Building efficient market-beating portfolios requires time, education, and a lot of computing power!

The Portfolio Architect is an AI-driven system that provides multiple benefits to our users by leveraging cutting-edge machine learning algorithms, statistical analysis, and predictive modeling to automate the process of asset selection and portfolio construction, saving time and reducing human error for individual and institutional investors.

Try AI Portfolio Architect
When determining whether Carnival is a strong investment it is important to analyze Carnival's competitive position within its industry, examining market share, product or service uniqueness, and competitive advantages. Beyond financials and market position, potential investors should also consider broader economic conditions, industry trends, and any regulatory or geopolitical factors that may impact Carnival's future performance. For an informed investment choice regarding Carnival Stock, refer to the following important reports:
Check out Carnival Piotroski F Score and Carnival Altman Z Score analysis.
For more information on how to buy Carnival Stock please use our How to buy in Carnival Stock guide.
You can also try the Instant Ratings module to determine any equity ratings based on digital recommendations. Macroaxis instant equity ratings are based on combination of fundamental analysis and risk-adjusted market performance.
Is Hotels, Resorts & Cruise Lines space expected to grow? Or is there an opportunity to expand the business' product line in the future? Factors like these will boost the valuation of Carnival. If investors know Carnival will grow in the future, the company's valuation will be higher. The financial industry is built on trying to define current growth potential and future valuation accurately. All the valuation information about Carnival listed above have to be considered, but the key to understanding future value is determining which factors weigh more heavily than others.
Quarterly Earnings Growth
0.599
Earnings Share
1.17
Revenue Per Share
19.351
Quarterly Revenue Growth
0.152
Return On Assets
0.0425
The market value of Carnival is measured differently than its book value, which is the value of Carnival that is recorded on the company's balance sheet. Investors also form their own opinion of Carnival's value that differs from its market value or its book value, called intrinsic value, which is Carnival's true underlying value. Investors use various methods to calculate intrinsic value and buy a stock when its market value falls below its intrinsic value. Because Carnival's market value can be influenced by many factors that don't directly affect Carnival's underlying business (such as a pandemic or basic market pessimism), market value can vary widely from intrinsic value.
Please note, there is a significant difference between Carnival's value and its price as these two are different measures arrived at by different means. Investors typically determine if Carnival is a good investment by looking at such factors as earnings, sales, fundamental and technical indicators, competition as well as analyst projections. However, Carnival's price is the amount at which it trades on the open market and represents the number that a seller and buyer find agreeable to each party.